For faster navigation, this Iframe is preloading the Wikiwand page for
User:Ghren/工作區53.
學術論文中對中文維基百科條目的批評:
趙士林、張亞瓊在2020年批擊了上海外來人口問題。該條目在2013年5月16日19時23分「守望者爱孟创建。兩位所批評的版本是該條目在2019年6月22日前後的情況。截至6月22日,该条目累计被修订668次,共有101名独立编辑对此条目做过 贡献,最新版本为92282字节。條目共分為了八個欄目,而犯罪性問題和群體間對立占比最高,分別為20.4%和29.5%。
在當時的版本中,在犯罪问题”列举了11起犯罪事件,前5起在案件名中开头均出现了具体省份:“安徽盗窃团伙毁坏上海文物案”“安徽帮酒吧聚众砍人案”等,将犯罪问题直接与地域相连接,为条目增加了明显了地域歧视偏向。此外,當時也將杨佳袭警案与复旦投毒案也归于外来人口犯罪问题,但在案件中并未提及地区,并无引文也不能說明这两起案件与外来人口犯罪问题的任何联系。
再者,條目中有些句子引用時並不當。
說明文字
問題 |
引用 |
條目內容
|
過度引申 |
外來流動的文化素質偏低 |
低素質外來人口
|
過度總結 |
據統計,在1990年...分別是43.7%,53.6%,51% |
外來人口犯罪率較本地居民為高
|
以偏概全 |
來源為市民的來信個案 |
隨外來就業,就醫人員涌入,本地居民的就醫環境不斷惡化,使部份上海居民對現況感到不滿
|
誇大修辭 |
來源只針對個別現象 |
有很多患者為了治病,不得不進上海看醫生,全國資源都調往這
|
賦予他意 |
「聽說有幾個外地人專門在附近的一些小區收集社保卡」 |
外來不法人員
|
篡改原意 |
部份滬上的網友的非議正因為此,甚至演變為異味的地域攻擊 |
但其中也反映出上海網友對於日益增加的外來人員上漲感到不滿
|
沒有來源 |
來源沒有提及安徵籍 |
上海一出租車司機下班回家時,遭到多名安徽籍醉漢襲擊
|
{{bottomLinkPreText}}
{{bottomLinkText}}
This page is based on a Wikipedia article written by
contributors (read/edit).
Text is available under the
CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
{{current.index+1}} of {{items.length}}
Thanks for reporting this video!
This browser is not supported by Wikiwand :(
Wikiwand requires a browser with modern capabilities in order to provide you with the best reading experience.
Please download and use one of the following browsers:
An extension you use may be preventing Wikiwand articles from loading properly.
If you're using HTTPS Everywhere or you're unable to access any article on Wikiwand, please consider switching to HTTPS (https://www.wikiwand.com).
An extension you use may be preventing Wikiwand articles from loading properly.
If you are using an Ad-Blocker, it might have mistakenly blocked our content.
You will need to temporarily disable your Ad-blocker to view this page.
✕
This article was just edited, click to reload
Please click Add in the dialog above
Please click Allow in the top-left corner,
then click Install Now in the dialog
Please click Open in the download dialog,
then click Install
Please click the "Downloads" icon in the Safari toolbar, open the first download in the list,
then click Install
{{::$root.activation.text}}
Follow Us
Don't forget to rate us
Oh no, there's been an error
Please help us solve this error by emailing us at
support@wikiwand.com
Let us know what you've done that caused this error, what browser you're using, and whether you have any special extensions/add-ons installed.
Thank you!